February 7, 2003     
     Doormen    Commerce St.    Slow Food    Graveyard Shift    The M60    Off Stage  
     All Photos: The Cherry Lane Theatre
The Cherry Lane Theatre is one of Manhattan's oldest Off-Broadway theaters.   Photo: Andy Glockner
Tucked away on a quiet corner of Commerce Street is the oldest continuously running Off-Broadway theater in New York.  If only people could find The Cherry Lane Theatre.

There are no signs on Seventh Avenue South to point theatergoers in the right direction, unlike the 1950's when a brick wall facing the busy thoroughfare was painted with the theater's logo and a large arrow to direct the crowds to Commerce Street.  Advertisements dating back to its beginnings in 1924 have had to add that the playhouse is three blocks south of Sheridan Square.

"Even people that live around here don't know the theater is there," said Faye Armon, audience director at The Cherry Lane.  "People always have trouble finding it. It's just tucked away in this little magical neighborhood."

As hard as it can be to find, The Cherry Lane Theatre has produced plays by some of the most well-known and critically acclaimed American playwrights and actors.  Still looking a bit like the farm building it once was, the theater has played host to the likes of Sam Shepard's "True West" in 1987, Samuel Beckett's "Happy Days" in 1961, Edward Albee's "The American Dream" in 1960 and F. Scott Fitzgerald's "The Vegetable" in 1926.  It is a theater aficionado's theater, attracting actors, directors, producers and playwrights through its cherry red doors and velvet curtains, onto a small wooden stage that has seen the evolution of the last 78 years of theater.

Housed in an 1817 farm silo and one-time box factory, The Cherry Lane's stage has been walked by James Earl Jones, Tyne Daly, Kevin Bacon, Gene Hackman, Julia Roberts, Ethan Hawke, Olympia Dukakis, John Malkovich and Gary Sinise.  Its Mentoring and Master's Class programs are supported by two of the most outstanding arts programs in the country - Yale School of Drama and The Juilliard School.  The theater saw the birth of the Living Theatre and Theatre of the Absurd, as plays for these movements were premiered and showcased at The Cherry Lane.

The Cherry Lane Theatre celebrate its 75th anniversay in 1999.  Photo: The Cherry Lane Theatre
Founded in 1924 by the poet Edna St. Vincent Millay, scenic designer Cleon Throckmorton, and a group of intellectuals, artists and writers, The Cherry Lane became known as a place from which new talent emerged.  Over the years, 38 Commerce Street housed companies like the Lenox Hill Players, Paul and Virginia Gilmore's Mystery Theater and the Jitney Vagabond Players.  The theater was bought in 1996 by the Little Goddess, Inc., which also maintains The Jose Quintero Theatre on 42nd Street.

In 1997, the company started the Cherry Lane Alternative Theatre, a non-profit organization.  Headed by artistic
director Angelina Fiordellisi, the studio theater furthers the theater's long-held mission to discover, nurture and produce new talent.

The Mentoring Project, which pairs three selected new playwrights with seasoned professionals for a year-long process of working toward a showcase production, is the organization's cornerstone.  Some of the plays, such as "Saint Lucy's Eyes" by Bridgette Wimberly, have moved on to other theaters.  But even for those whose plays will not move on, The Cherry Lane provides a starting point, a place where new voices can be heard and new forms of theater can be experimented.

"Sure Broadway has 'The Producers' and 'Mama Mia.'  Occasionally, it will have a really great play," Armon said.  "But generally, in Off-Broadway, The Cherry Lane included, we're able to experiment more and to hear new voices and try new things.  And possibly, maybe get someone to think out there."

Aspiring playwright Carmen Pelaez, who already wrote and produced a one-woman play in Miami, came on a February night to The Cherry Lane Studio's Master Class program to hear Wendy Wasserstein, author of "The Heidi Chronicles" and "The Sisters Rosensweig."  Palaez, who has lived in New York for 10 years, hoped to find some secret to the trade - to break through and get to a place where she could sustain her love of moving people through words.

"I want an insight that will help in the process of creating something in the hopes that it outlives you and doesn't die in your drawer," said Palaez, 31.  "It's a lot easier to fail, because then you can validate it to no end and then it's a success.  When you're a success, it's hard to maintain.  I guess I've had my 15 minutes of fame and it was not nearly enough for me."

Wasserstein, after hearing about the play at the Master Class meeting, told Pelaez to submit it for the Mentor Project and to try again at some of the places she had tried the first time around.  The Pulitzer Prize-winning playwright rattled off other advice for the novice - "Find a smart producer," "It's your play," "Find the right place to do theater."

For many, that advice has led back to The Cherry Lane, where the people who run it are bound and determined by their mission statement to provide a nurturing environment for young artists and a great theater experience for those watching.  And if the theater company can just get people to the hidden playhouse without getting them lost or turned around, they might just last another 78 years.

 
© 2003 NYC24, a production of the New Media Workshop at the Columbia University Graduate School of Journalism.