| |
 |
| Freshmen
X and Y illustrate an intimate talking distance in the Lerner
Student Center at Columbia University. |
Different
cultural ideas of personal space come into play the moment you approach
someone…or try to. Each culture has its own standards on what qualifies
as too close, too far and just right.
n
the United States, the accepted distance for conversation
is about 18 inches, said Cornelius Grove, principal at Cornelius
Grove & Associates, an international management consulting firm
based in New York that specializes in cross-cultural training.
The
closest distance between two people in a conversation
takes place in Middle Eastern cultures, said David Givens,
director of the nonprofit Center for Nonverbal Studies in Spokane,
Wash.
 |
|
PHOTO:
Michael Arnone
|
|
Getting
up close and personal is common between men and women who
are friends in America. In traditional Middle Eastern and
Southern Asian cultures, though, men and women segregate themselves.
Enjoying a quiet moment together are X and Y.
|
Men usually talk to each other at very short distances, and they
even push and shove each other, said Hilka
Klinkenberg, an international etiquette consultant.
The distance between two people in a conversation is also very close
in Latin America, said Grove. When people from the United
States or Europe see Latin Americans moving in close to speak to
them, they often perceive the close distance as an invasion of the
private space.
n
the other end of the distance spectrum, Asians tend to keep
much more distance between each other than Westerners do, Klinkenberg
said. "When two people bow to one another, they can't be that close,"
she said, noting they would knock heads if they were.
The
perception of personal space is very strong in Japan, Givens
says. Crossing between two people or intruding into another's space
to move through a crowded room is seen as ruder than in other cultures.
"The
British keep also big distances when they talk to each other,"
said Givens. Klinkenberg agreed and mentioned the legendary story
of a British diplomat and an Arab diplomat speaking at a party.
The Arab kept moving forward, while the Briton kept backing away
to establish the distance at which he felt most comfortable. The
result was a comical chase around the party hall, the Briton backing
away with the Arab in pursuit.
Return
to Top
|
|
|
A
Room with a View?
|
|
Perception
of the space at work is not universal. According to Hilka
Klinkenberg, an international etiquette consultant , Americans
have a pretty unique view of office structure.
"Only
Americans strive for the corner office, away from the rest
of their co-workers," she said. That is not the case in France,
where the boss's desk is in the center of the room and power
radiates out to the room's edge.
 |
|
PHOTO:
Michael Arnone
|
| Life
at the top: David Klatell, Assistant Dean of Columbia
Graduate School of Journalism, works in his top-floor
corner office. |
"If they give you the corner office, you're out of the loop,"
Klinkenberg said. "They're pushing out you the door."
In
the United States, cubicles replaced the more exposed "pool"
desks, which had earlier lined the floors of group-occupied
workrooms.
Germans
visiting the U.S. see the open doors in offices and businesses
as indicative of an unusually relaxed and "unbusinesslike"
attitude, said researcher David Givens. Americans in return
get the feeling that the Germans' closed doors conceal "a
secretive or conspiratorial operation."
|
|
"He's a close-talker."
Personal Space on TV
|
|
"
Don't fence me in
Let me ride through
The wild open country that I love Don't fence me in"
--- Cole Porter, Don't Fence Me In
"
What do you think of him?
- He's a close-talker."
--- Seinfeld
"Why
did you back out on our deal?
- I didn't make a deal. I just shook your hand.
- Well, that's a deal where I come from.
- We come from the same place!"
--- Seinfeld
"They shook hands and swore brothers"
--- William Shakespeare, As You Like It
"Hold
me closer, hold me closer...
- If I hold you any closer, I'll be in back of you!"
--- Groucho Marx, A Day at the Races
|
|