View of Chrysler Building from Grand Street in Chinatown.
PHOTO: Martin Skovmand

hen Roger and Katy Chan started a garment factory almost a decade ago in Chinatown, they had dreams of being successful and of helping new immigrants get their feet on the ground. But thanks to skyrocketing real-estate prices in New York City, they are about to say good bye to six years of business and over 40 employees, the majority of whom are Chinese immigrants with base-level education, and a language barrier that makes it difficult for them to find work.

“The rent goes up five percent, every year and that’s fine,” says Chan, who now pays $15 per square foot, up from $10 when the business first started. “The problem is that the Internet firms are paying anywhere from $24 to $60 per square foot, and we cannot afford that. The landlord doesn’t want to renew our lease.”

Their business, Essence Fashion on 215-217 Grand St., is one of 400 garment factories that have been affected by the increasing number of Internet and Wall Street investments in the area, according to a press release by the Center for an Urban Future, a nonprofit organization.

As midtown’s Garment Center and Chinatown continue to attract the money-minting Silicon Alley industry, apparel manufacturers are mostly shutting down or moving to outer boroughs and New Jersey because they cannot compete with the inflated real-estate prices spreading through the area like a bush fire.

At a press conference held in late February 2000 in the heart of the Garment Center in midtown Manhattan, small business owners challenged City Hall. “It has not demonstrated support for this important industry as it has ‘glitzy, cash-rich new media and Wall Street industries,” says Jonathan Bowles, a research director with the Center for an Urban Future.

Other officials from the organization, Center for an Urban Future, together with representatives from unions have asked the mayor’s office to reinforce New York City’s ignored zoning law. At stake are the jobs of 75,000 garment workers and of 48,000 others in the wholesale apparel industry, union officials say.

The city is allowing building owners to sidestep a zoning law that requires landlords to reserve 50 percent of all space on the side streets in the Garment Center for manufacturing, says Bowles. The zoning law was meant to protect garment factories from steep rent increases, but enforcement efforts stopped back in 1993, Bowles says.

“What happened to city planning?” says May Ying Chen, the vice-president of a textile allied workers union called UNITE. “What happened to a city that cares about its residents needs? People should not have to be unemployed, and workers cannot afford to commute to New Jersey every day. We don’t oppose these new industries; we just want to be able to live as well.”

According to a press release from the Center for an Urban Future, City Hall failed to address the growing space crunch affecting industrial businesses throughout the city, or come up with a strategy to help garment manufacturers thrive outside of Manhattan. The city’s department of Housing Development did not return phone calls.

Another report by the nonprofit organization titled, “The Empire Has No Clothes,’ revealed that in 1998, for the first time, fashion-related firms accounted for less than half of all businesses in the Garment Center.

 

 

 

 

 

Interior of a Garment Factory in Chinatown.
PHOTO: Martin Skovmand

 

 

 

Source: Center for an Urban Future